Martial Arts vs School Sports for Kids - Which Option Builds More Confidence?
If you want to raise happy, successful kids, you must instill a sense of confidence in your child. Physical activities and challenges such as school sports and martial arts for kids are crucial tools for developing self-confidence.Unfortunately, kids have limited time available for any given activity. This constraint forces us as parents to decide between martial arts or school sports for our kids.
In terms of martial arts vs school sports for confidence, we firmly believe that martial arts are superior to most school sports activities. The following article lays out our rationale for putting your child in a martial arts program for kids. Our primary focus in this discussion is developing confidence. Hopefully, by the end, you will have an understanding of why martial arts are better than school sports for confidence.
What is Confidence?
Confidence is an incredibly common term. Discussions of child-development and helping kids succeed in life frequently stress the importance of confidence. But what does confidence actually mean? According to Psychology Today, confidence in children revolves around an internal belief that the child can succeed in a given activity. A child with well-developed self-confidence “displays a belief in his or her own abilities.”
We can develop self-confidence in children through the following:
- Mirroring and encouraging our children.
- Making a child believe that you trust them.
- Helping children see their own skill development.
Any child can develop this sense of self-confidence. As parents, our job is to guide our children towards activities that further this goal. We also must provide mirroring and encouragement as they engage in these activities. With these parameters in mind, it becomes increasingly obvious that martial arts for kids for confidence are an amazing way to help your child meet these goals. Ultimately this leads them towards becoming confident in themselves.
How Martial Arts Build Confidence
In life, we are all faced with constant challenges, both large and small. Overcoming these challenges over the short and long term ultimately leads us to grow and flourish. While no individual’s personal challenges will be the same, we must cultivate the confidence in ourselves to attempt these challenges. Confidence lies in both the feeling that you can overcome an obstacle as well as the willingness to accept that you may fail along the way, but you will try again despite this ‘failure.'
The Goals of Martial Arts
Martial arts is fundamentally about overcoming difficult challenges in the face of adversity. Controlling another human being via our own physical abilities and knowledge is a serious physical challenge. As we find success in the dojo and on the mats through our skill development, we become more confident overall in our ability to face adversity and emerge stronger at the end.When it comes to martial arts for kids, your child will be faced with adversity in the dojo early into their career as martial artists. There is no way around the fact that all martial artists will face humbling, difficult ‘defeat’ against those with more experience. In fact, for most of us, this reality is persistent regardless of how long we have been training martial arts.
The advantage of developing confidence in children is that adversity in the dojo is carefully controlled to ensure that your child remains as safe as possible in the wake of physical challenges. The child can be progressed through calibrated difficulty via training partner selection. On the flip side, your child's involvement in a semi or full-contact martial art does have a chance for injury and greater uncertainty in the outcome of winning or losing.
The acknowledgment of risk and the completion of a task in the face of this risk in itself builds a massive amount of confidence and self-belief. This may simply a matter of your child getting through their first martial arts tournament or earning their first promotion. Both are big milestones in early development as a martial artist. As with all great things in life, martial arts rewards those who are dedicated and disciplined. Training martial arts guarantees your child the feeling of accomplishment from serious training.
Why Martial Arts are Better Than School Sports
Hopefully, by now you are convinced that martial arts for kids are excellent for building confidence. However, you might wonder “don’t traditional school sports have the same effect?” The answer is yes… sometimes. School sports can certainly develop your child’s confidence and ability to work with others cooperatively to achieve a common goal. Nevertheless, there are some downsides and missing components when it comes to traditional school sports for children. These downsides make martial arts for kids better than school sports for developing confidence.
#1 - School Sports Reward Athletically Gifted Children More Than Less Athletic Kids
While competition can be an important aspect of self-development, in traditional sports, it’s incredibly common for non-athletic children to get far less play time than their more talented peers. Often, the children who get the most kudos from team sports are naturally faster, more coordinated, and physically talented. The less athletic kids are then relegated to being bench-warmers and backups. Many may not even step foot on the field come game-day.
Compare this to martial arts for kids. Even a non-athletic kid placed in martial arts at too old of an age to be a 10-year-old prodigy will still receive the opportunity to compete against a child of similar skill. Due to the individual nature of martial arts, kids are (usually) not blamed for the team’s loss, nor will they be benched simply because another kid is better at the game. Even at the lowest level of competition, children get to be in the spotlight and receive social acknowledgment and reward. Be sure to mirror the accomplishment to your child for showing up to compete and putting it all on the line against the opponent, win or lose.
#2 - Martial Arts Develops a Real Life Skill
Most of us in the first world can acknowledge that we live in some of the statistically safest times in human history. Sure, there are bad neighborhoods, crime, and wars, but the relative level of violence your average first-world child will experience is incredibly low. Nevertheless, it is incredibly likely that at some point, your child will be faced with a real-life encounter resulting in physical altercation. This could be as mundane as a schoolyard bully encounter, or more serious situations involving violent crime. In either case, the presence of violence or potential for violence is incredibly traumatic, and in a few short moments can change one’s life entirely.
Of course, we should always encourage our children to walk away, turn the other cheek, and avoid confrontation. However, there may be a time when the fight cannot be avoided. In this case, the ability of children to defend themselves effectively enough to escape may be a life-saving skill.In school sports, the skills themselves are really only applicable during the game itself. Martial arts skill transcends the gym and the competition. The confidence associated with at least knowing the basics of how to fight another person far outweigh the brief rush of a soccer participation trophy (where your child may not have even played in the game!).
#3 - Martial Arts Teach Kids to Cooperate
It may seem on a surface level that traditional team sports would be better than martial arts for kids for teamwork and cooperation. After all, in order to get a touch-down or score a soccer goal, the kids must work together and learn to cooperate. It's certainly true that in the context of high-level children’s sports with qualified coaches, the victory will be secured by good teamwork. However, this completely overlooks the fact that at lower levels, one or two athletic kids can dominate a game, score all the goals, and skip over the need to pass the ball or play with the team.
This take on school sports versus martial arts for kids also shows a fundamental lack of understanding about the dynamics of martial arts training. While martial arts are fundamentally about one opponent versus another, the vast majority of training time in martial arts is spent on cooperative training activities. In order to drill the techniques, students must work together cooperatively to practice the moves and avoid injury.If a kid cannot work with others, they will not be able to advance in martial arts. They will need to develop the interpersonal skills required for cooperative drilling. Even in a sparring context, children must take care of one another. In this way, martial arts are actually better than many traditional team sports settings, where gifted kids can be “ball hogs” and ruin the entire experience for the bench-warmers. Martial arts build confidence in less athletic children. They instill real-world skills learned in quality martial arts programs. Additionally, they instill effective cooperation with others. Collectively these traits make martial arts a better choice than school sports for kids.
FAQ
Won’t my child get injured in martial arts?
Physical altercations, by definition, involve physical risk to the participants. As such you're probably wondering whether your child will be injured during martial arts training. The answer is yes, most likely your child will injure themself at some point during the course of their training. Injuries are a normal part of being human. This is particularly so when participating in any sport.
We need a discussion of these injury risks in context. Injuries are a reality in all sports. In fact, for the most part, the injury rates during martial arts training are not substantially higher than in mainstream sports. The specific risk and typical injury profile will vary depending on the sport and martial art. Additionally, some martial arts do carry inherently more risk than certain sports or other martial arts. Nevertheless, the risk of injury in martial arts should not be the reason you put your kid in traditional sports.
Additionally, consider the risks of your child not participating in any physical activity. These include obesity, cardiovascular risks, and ultimately setting your child up for a life of inactivity. The long term risks of this inactivity are far more serious you compare them to the possibility of sprains, strains, and even broken bones.
Will Martial Arts Make My Child Violent?
Another concern you may face is the worry that martial arts will make your kid violent. Martial arts certainly give children the tools to really hurt each other badly. However, people commonly become less violent as their skill increases in martial arts.There are many reasons for this happening. These include greater knowledge of the true consequences of physical violence and that the child has less to ‘prove’ on the playground. After all, if they head to the dojo after school, what does a playground fight really prove? A child’s antisocial behavior may be so great that they are simply hell-bent on hurting others. Martial arts is unlikely to make this urge worse. In fact, competitive martial arts might provide a better outlet for aggressive tendencies. If the child is still violent towards others, your considerations are bigger than whether picking between soccer or BJJ.
Which Martial Art Should I Choose for My Child?
Hopefully, we've convinced you that martial arts are better for your child than school sports. However, you might wonder which martial art you should choose for your child. We havemany great answers to this question. The most important thing is to find a good instructor. We recommend the following process:
- Look up gyms in your area
- Read online reviews
- Talk to other parents
- Check out several gyms and dojo in your area.
- Choose the best fit for your child
The second consideration should be to pick a martial art that involves live training and sparring. There are many options in this regard, the following are our top picks
- Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu
- Muay Thai
- Wrestling
- Boxing
- Karate
All of these can be great options if you find a good coach. If your child’s school has a wrestling team this could be a good choice and convenient as well (although it may be plagued by some of the issues with team sports depending on the culture).An additional consideration worth noting is that striking arts typically involve more physical pain and head trauma than grappling arts. With this in mind, starting off with BJJ for kids may be a good option for kids martial arts for confidence. They can branch out later if they are so inclined.
In Conclusion: Pick Martial Arts for Your Kid!
At this point, we’ve laid out our best arguments for picking martial arts for kids. That’s not to say that you shouldn’t ever involve your kids in school sports either in addition to or instead of martial arts. The most important thing will always be your child’s enjoyment, and forcing a kid to do karate when they really want to play tennis is probably not a great choice.Nevertheless, if your child is a blank slate or is open to trying out new activities, our vote lies firmly in the camp of choosing martial arts for kids.